After this lesson you can describe how CrowdStrike Falcon, SentinelOne Singularity and Microsoft Defender for Endpoint present their architecture and main features, explain what a managed detection and response (MDR) service adds, explain what the 19 July 2024 CrowdStrike content-update failure shows about the risks of any security agent, and plan a careful EDR pilot for ships.
Lesson 20 explained what EDR and XDR are. This lesson makes the ideas concrete with three platforms that a shipping company is likely to meet when it asks for proposals: CrowdStrike Falcon, SentinelOne Singularity and Microsoft Defender for Endpoint. There are other capable products; these three are chosen because they are widely discussed and each takes a slightly different approach.
Comparing security products is like comparing three shipyards from their brochures: each brochure is accurate about what the yard offers, but none tells you how a particular ship will perform in your trade. So this lesson does two things. It describes each product only in the words its maker publishes, and it then explains how to test the claims on your own ships before you commit a fleet.
Product names, bundles and features change often. Everything below reflects the vendors' public pages as read in November 2026; check the current documentation before you buy.
1. CrowdStrike Falcon
CrowdStrike sells Falcon as a platform of modules that share one agent, the Falcon sensor, and a cloud back end. The modules a beginner meets first are:
In short, CrowdStrike's design leans on its cloud: the agent sends telemetry up, and much of the correlation and intelligence happens centrally. For ships, the obvious question is how much protection remains on board when the satellite link is down — CrowdStrike states its prevention works offline, and Section 5 explains how to check that on your own vessels.
2. SentinelOne Singularity
SentinelOne presents Singularity as one agent for endpoint and identity protection, with an emphasis on automated response and recovery. Its endpoint page highlights these features:
SentinelOne also describes its agent as “architected to minimize kernel interactions”, with controlled updates and rollout. Rollback is attractive for ships, where reinstalling a computer far from shore can take days; but as with any automatic action, decide in advance which systems it may touch.
3. Microsoft Defender for Endpoint
Microsoft describes Defender for Endpoint as an enterprise endpoint security platform to help organisations prevent, detect, investigate and respond to advanced threats, and as the endpoint part of Microsoft Defender XDR (Lesson 20). Its Windows documentation describes a “lightweight behavioral sensor” that is built into the operating system, which is why turning it on for a Windows fleet is mainly a matter of onboarding and configuration rather than installing a new agent. It also runs on macOS, Linux, Android and iOS.
The agent relies on Microsoft Defender Antivirus for some capabilities such as file scanning. If a device uses another vendor's antivirus, Microsoft Defender Antivirus switches to passive mode and stops its own real-time scanning — worth knowing if a ship's PCs already run another product.
For a company already on Microsoft 365 and Microsoft Sentinel (Lesson 18), the attraction is integration: endpoint, email and identity alerts arrive in the same portal and can flow into the same SIEM.
4. MDR, and a Lesson from 19 July 2024
Managed detection and response (MDR) means the vendor or a partner provides the people who watch the EDR console 24 hours a day. All three vendors offer one, as shown above. For a shipping company that cannot staff its own round-the-clock SOC (Lesson 16), MDR is often the realistic way to make EDR useful. Two things still stay with the company: deciding which response actions the provider may take on which systems, and keeping the incident response plan that tells the provider whom to call — on a ship, usually the master and the technical superintendent.
The second half of this section is a reminder that the security agent is itself powerful software. What follows is taken from CrowdStrike's own technical statement and a Microsoft blog post.
The lesson is not about one vendor; any product that runs deep in the operating system and updates itself frequently can fail in a similar way. For a ship, a faulty update that stops a computer from booting is a safety and operations problem, and recovery may need someone with hands on the keyboard. So whichever product you choose, ask the vendor how you can control the timing of sensor and content updates — for example, staging them so a few test machines receive them before the fleet — and keep recovery procedures and offline media on board.
5. Choosing and Piloting EDR for a Fleet
No published brochure answers the questions that matter at sea. A short pilot on a few representative ships does. A sensible pilot checks at least these points:
IACS UR E26 4.2.3 asks for malware protection on every computer-based system in its scope, and asks the systems integrator to document, for each system, the protection mechanisms approved by the supplier. In practice that means the product choice for bridge and machinery systems is often made, or at least constrained, by the equipment maker, whose UR E27 obligations include providing a malicious code protection capability that can be updated. A shipowner may standardise on one EDR for its office and crew networks and still accept a different, supplier-approved protection on an integrated bridge system.
E26 also asks the shipowner to show at survey that anti-malware software has been maintained and updated. A modern EDR console makes that evidence easy to produce — which ships are up to date, which have not checked in — provided someone looks at it. And E26 4.3.1's rule that intrusion detection on in-scope networks must be passive is a good guide for EDR too: on systems the ship depends on, prefer detection and alerting to automatic action, and leave the decision to isolate a machine to people who understand the ship.
- CrowdStrike Falcon: one lightweight sensor with a cloud-native back end (Threat Graph); Falcon Prevent is stated to work offline; Insight XDR adds EDR/XDR and Real Time Response.
- SentinelOne Singularity: behavioural AI on a single agent, Storyline attack narratives, rollback without reimaging, and Purple AI for plain-language investigation.
- Microsoft Defender for Endpoint: sensor built into Windows; Plan 1 gives NGAV, attack surface reduction and manual response; Plan 2 (in Microsoft 365 E5) adds full EDR, automation and hunting.
- All three offer 24/7 MDR — Falcon Complete, Wayfinder MDR, Defender Experts MDR — but the company still decides which actions are allowed and keeps its incident response plan.
- The 19 July 2024 CrowdStrike content update crashed Windows hosts (about 8.5 million devices by Microsoft's estimate); it was not a cyberattack. Any security agent needs controlled, staged updates and on-board recovery procedures.
- Pilot on representative ships: offline behaviour, bandwidth, detection, response rules, update control and fit with SIEM and licences — and use only supplier-approved protection on E26-scope systems.
- CrowdStrike — Falcon Prevent next-generation antivirus
- CrowdStrike — Falcon Insight XDR
- CrowdStrike — Threat Graph
- CrowdStrike — Falcon Complete MDR
- CrowdStrike — Technical details: Falcon content update for Windows hosts (July 2024)
- Microsoft — Helping our customers through the CrowdStrike outage (20 July 2024)
- SentinelOne — Singularity Endpoint Protection Platform
- SentinelOne — Wayfinder Managed Detection & Response
- Microsoft Learn — Microsoft Defender for Endpoint
- Microsoft Learn — Microsoft Defender for Endpoint on Windows
- Microsoft Learn — Overview of Defender for Endpoint Plan 1
- Microsoft Learn — Overview of endpoint detection and response capabilities
- Microsoft Learn — What is Microsoft Defender Experts MDR?
- IACS UR E26 Rev.1 (Nov 2023), Cyber resilience of ships — sections 4.2.3 and 4.3.1
- IACS UR E27 Rev.1 (Sep 2023), Cyber resilience of on-board systems and equipment
Product capabilities are quoted or summarised from each vendor's own public pages as read in November 2026; they are the vendors' claims, not independent test results, and plan contents and names change. Product names are used for teaching, not as an endorsement. The pilot checklist is general guidance.
Captain Paul writes the Maritime Cybersecurity Learning Roadmap on ShipPaulJobs — a step-by-step course that takes readers from security fundamentals to the cyber resilience rules that now apply to ships.
← Course Index LinkedIn⚓ Join the ShipPaulJobs Community
Join →

Comments
Post a Comment